Giants Use McCarthy as Backup in Week 5 Commanders Tie

The New York Giants used J.J. McCarthy as their backup quarterback in a Week 5 overtime tie against the Washington Commanders at Northwest Stadium, where the team moved to 3-1-1 after a 27-27 finish on Sunday.

According to Sports Yahoo, Jameis Winston remained the starter and completed 33 of 54 passes for 326 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions as New York erased a 14-point second-half deficit.

The Giants changed McCarthy’s role before the game after acquiring him from the Minnesota Vikings, according to Heavy. The former 2024 first-round pick had previously worked as the No. 3 quarterback while learning the offense.

Fans reacted after the Giants announced McCarthy had moved into the backup role behind Winston. One supporter said the team’s confidence remained with the veteran quarterback.

"Plenty of confidence in Jameis. Won’t need 3 today," said @patrickmiller86.

Another fan predicted McCarthy could eventually take over the starting position after his promotion on the depth chart.

"He will be starting after the bye," said @UndertheMDsun1.

A third reaction focused on how the Giants might use McCarthy during games rather than only listing him as the backup quarterback.

"McCarthy as the 2 is one thing, actually dialing up a package for him is another. Either commit to the plays or don’t bother dressing him for it," said @frznsports.

McCarthy made his Giants debut against Washington and played five offensive snaps, according to Sports Yahoo. The report said Washington anticipated RPO or designed quarterback run concepts, limiting him to two yards on two carries.

The Giants played 89 offensive snaps, 62 defensive snaps and 33 special teams snaps in Week 5, according to Sports Yahoo. Malik Nabers caught 11 passes for 121 yards and a touchdown, while Isaiah Likely recorded 11 receptions for 94 yards and two scores.

Cam Skattebo’s overtime fumble ended a potential game-winning drive, while Washington allowed the clock to expire within field-goal range, according to Sports Yahoo. New York also dealt with lineup changes, including Marcus Mbow taking 45 snaps after Jermaine Eluemunor left with a calf issue.